Grizzly BullsShould 401(k) Plans Dive Into New Waters?
Table of Contents
A fresh wave of innovation is making a splash in the 401(k) world. But is it smooth sailing ahead, or should we be worried about sharks in the water?
Introducing New Ideas: Imagine this: a startup launches, offering a 401(k) plan that throws the rulebook overboard. No longer are you limited to the traditional stock-and-bond mix. Instead, this new plan lets you wade into deep, uncharted waters. Think: collectibles, farmland, or even that brewery down the street you’ve been eyeing as a dream investment.
Sounds exciting, right? But before you dive in, it's worth considering a few important questions. Does this new way of retirement planning come with risks that lurk below the surface? And more importantly, do most people even want to dive that deep into investment complexity?
The Dream of Diversification: Smooth Sailing?
On paper, this startup’s idea makes a lot of sense. As Harry Markowitz (of Nobel fame) once said, good portfolios don’t just rely on a high rate of return or low risk—they also rely on how those investments work together. If one zigs while the other zags, you’re in good shape! Adding exotic investments like timberland or startup equity should, in theory, provide that much-needed zig-zag combo.
In fact, modern portfolio theory teaches us that the more diversified your investments, the smoother your sailing could be over the long term. Traditional stocks and bonds might all move in the same direction during a market storm, but those alpaca farms or rare comic book collections? They just might stay dry.
A Hypothetical Portfolio Breakdown:
| Asset Type | Expected Return | Risk (Volatility) | Correlation with Stocks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large Cap Stocks | 7% | High | 1.00 |
| Bonds | 3% | Low | -0.20 |
| Real Estate (REITs) | 6% | Medium | 0.40 |
| Startups (VC Funds) | 12% | Very High | 0.10 |
| Farmland | 5% | Medium | 0.30 |
From a diversification standpoint, this portfolio would sing in different pitches. But hold on—let’s not get carried away. Like a ship with no wind in its sails, there are other factors to consider.
The Choppy Waters of Fees
While it may seem appealing to invest in real estate, art collections, or that local startup you’ve heard about, fees have a way of pulling the wind from your sails. A study by two professors, William Jennings and Brian Payne, suggests that while diversification is great in theory, the real-world costs of accessing these asset classes can sink your returns. Their research found that, in many cases, the high fees of private investments like hedge funds and venture capital funds "eat diversification's lunch."
In other words, while these investments look good on paper, those hefty management fees can take a serious bite out of your retirement pie. And unlike a mutual fund, where fees are relatively transparent, alternative investments often come with hidden costs like transaction fees, administrative fees, and even liquidity issues.
Transparency Issues: Dark Waters Ahead
When you invest in Apple stock, it’s pretty easy to find detailed reports on the company’s performance. Public companies have to disclose a ton of information, and countless analysts are happy to help you interpret it. But when it comes to private real estate deals, cryptocurrency startups, or small business ventures? You might be flying blind.
And let’s face it: not all of us are seasoned sailors ready to navigate the murky waters of unlisted securities. Without a lighthouse to guide the way, investors may be left to rely on information from the seller—which, as any experienced investor knows, isn’t always the most reliable source.
To borrow from Ronald Reagan’s playbook, "Trust, but verify." But when it comes to many of these alternative investments, the "verify" part could be missing.
Will Employees Take the Plunge?
This brings us to a critical question: do regular 401(k) participants even want these exotic investments? History suggests that for most people, the answer might be a polite "no, thanks."
Two decades ago, there was a similar push for employees to open up brokerage accounts inside their 401(k)s, giving them the ability to trade individual stocks and customize their portfolios. But guess what? Hardly anyone bothered. Employees overwhelmingly preferred to stick with simpler, off-the-shelf investments like target-date funds.
In fact, target-date funds have exploded in popularity precisely because they remove complexity. Instead of choosing from thousands of stocks, bonds, and funds, all you have to do is pick a target year. The fund manager takes care of the rest—adjusting your asset allocation over time as you approach retirement. Simple, and effective.
Growth of Target-Date Funds in 401(k) Plans (2005-2023):
| Year | % of 401(k) Assets in Target-Date Funds |
|---|---|
| 2005 | 5% |
| 2010 | 13% |
| 2015 | 24% |
| 2020 | 40% |
| 2023 | 47% |
A Generation of Speculators?
Of course, there are always exceptions. Younger investors, particularly those in the millennial and Gen Z brackets, seem more open to unconventional ideas. After all, we’re talking about the generations that flocked to cryptocurrencies and NFTs, willing to bet their savings on digital art and meme stocks. It’s not crazy to think that, given the option, some would leap at the chance to invest in these alternative 401(k) options.
Rocket Dollar, one such startup in this space, is targeting precisely this crowd—those who dream of putting their retirement savings into rental properties, private equity, or even, yes, cryptocurrency. If that’s their thing, more power to them. But for most, the complexity and lack of transparency will likely steer them back to safer, more traditional waters.
Conclusion: An Ocean of Possibilities, or a Drop in the Bucket?
So, should 401(k) plans embrace alternative investments? The short answer is, it depends. For the adventurous few willing to navigate these choppy waters, alternatives can provide a wealth of diversification opportunities—if they can stomach the fees and risks. But for the vast majority of employees, the simplicity and reliability of traditional stocks and bonds will likely continue to be the safer harbor.
In the end, the financial seas are vast, and there’s room for all types of sailors. Just make sure you know what you’re getting into before you set sail.
Fair winds and safe retirement planning!
